How many fish in a 10 gal?

emothman

New Member
I am starting a 10, and haven't gotten a clearish answer on how many fish I can have in it. I was hoping to house a pair of percula clowns? Is this too much? I am sure someone has tried, what has your experience been? Let me know.

Here is my plan
96W quad pc (50/50)
carbon and phosphate remover in cheapo walmart filter (w/o their media)
possibly get a skimmer later.
15 lbs live rock
live sand
probably a small powerhead (like 120-200 gph) since the filter is really slow.

Any recommendations?
 

Braxis

New Member
You could go to Petsmart and get the petsmart brand filter which is the tetra whisper you could get a thirty gallon filter for about 20 dollars and the speed is adjustable on them as well. Just get the whisper replacements and you can add what ever media you want.
 

Trogdor

New Member
Welcome.

Your lighting sounds good. I doubt that you will need a skimmer if you keep up with the water changes. I would back off of the amount of live rock a bit. I would go around 7-8 pounds and have good aquascaping. This is something that I wish I would have done instead of cramming it all in my tank and having little room for new coral and their base rocks. You could probably go closer to 400gph on your total water flow. It will help keep detritus from settling on the sand bed. It sounds like you have a good grasp of the concepts and can't wait to see it setup.
 

skinson

New Member
Welcome matey! I have a clown, a damsel, and a fire gobi in my 12g nano. Along with the usual CUC of turbo's and hermits. No probs at all with the readings.
Dave
 

emothman

New Member
Great info! Thanks guys. I especially appreciate the fish list, exactly what I needed. I will try and do less rock. I have a dry piece that is beautifully shapped that I was hoping to seed, but maybe won't. Can't wait to get started. I will post pictures as I go. (And questions!)
 

Trogdor

New Member
Most people won't put an anemone under power compacts but i think that you might be able to get away with it in a 10g tank due to the depth. Personally I wouldn't attempt an anemone if this is your first tank. You need a stable tank, which is usually 6 months to a year old.
 

reefman23

New Member
I wouldnt ever suggest an anemone in a 10g tank no matter what kind of lighting. Most anemones love to move around and when they do they are bound to get sucked into a powerhead or filter.... you cdan imagine the mess that makes.

Jesse
 

The Kapenta Kid

New Member
You also have to consider that there is a trade off between fish and corals in a small tank. You can have more fish than are generally recommended, but the combination of their food and excrement will work against good conditions for corals. |t least that is what I understand. More experienced comment is welcome.
 

unwired

New Member
I'm fairly new to the Nano tank game myself (Though I've done larger marine tanks in the past) but I thought I'd share a bit of my current project with you.

I custom built my own Nano tank which is just shy of 9G. Rather than go the filter route I used a second 10G glass tank as a refugium (biological filter). The important thing here is that you need to look at your overall water displacment. For my 9G tank I have 19G of displacement, minus rock, sand etc... This helps me keep the water changes down and gives better balance to the overall setup.

The 10G glass tank was $10 and my pump was another $18. You'd need to add some sort of overflow to your main tank. Personally, even if you just had a 5G refugium/sump I think it would be helpful.

Anyhow, for my 19G of displacement I currently have two O. Clowns and one CopperBanded Butterfly. The butterfly is a baby but I've been catching some flack on other msg boards about having him in such a small tank. Additionally, I have a serpent starfish and a small cleaner crew (4 snails, 2 scarlet hermits, 2 blue leg and 2 red leg hermits). I fully believe that I could still add some more small stuff. I've been considering some green chromis as they will school together which is kinda cute to watch.

The last thing I'll leave you with is that I've also got a good amount of Macro algae in the refugium (both Chaeto and Calupera). These plants suck up the nitrates and help keep the tank in balance.

To date, my setup has been more stable than I anticipated and the cost of my nano (while higher than a stock glass tank) was still well within my budget.

Here's a quick fish photo:



Good luck & let us know how it goes.

:)
 

emothman

New Member
I am looking into sump stuff, and thinking about it. Thanks for the info on your setup. I have been spending hrs researching every day. My wife is getting a bit tired of it. I may need more help that way, then with the tank in the long run ;)
 

unwired

New Member
I don't know where you're located but there seems to be a bunch of good groups around the country. It shouldn't be too difficult to find people in your own neck of the woods who share similar interests and can give you pointers.
 
Top